A rare opportunity in one of the island’s most sought-after enclaves. In the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath designer’s cottage blends historic charm with modern versatility. With Chase Creek views from the front entry, the home is surrounded by the natural beauty and architectural character that define this storied district.
Ownership includes coveted Beach Club membership, with community tennis, a marina, beaches, cafs, shops, and the iconic Heights Pharmacy & Soda Fountain just steps away. Hotels and guest accommodations nearby make hosting easy. Inside, light-filled spaces are designed for comfort and entertaining.
The open kitchen and dining area flow to a cozy living room and media space, while the outdoor patio-with shower and BBQ-sets the stage for summer gatherings.
Upstairs, cedar-paneled pitched ceilings create a Scandinavian cottage feel, warmed by nautical accents. The property may also be purchased furnished for turnkey ease.
The finished lower level adds versatility with a media room, laundry, half bath, and separate entrance-perfect for guests or a home office.
Grounds offer potential for a pool, guest house, or studio, while business zoning expands possibilities. Shelter Island Heights is more than a neighborhood-it’s a legacy.
From tree-lined lanes and historic homes to golf, galleries, and sunset cocktails at The Pridwin or Sunset Beach, every island pleasure is close at hand. Whether a serene retreat, stylish pied–terre, or flexible investment, this move-in-ready home is a rare chance to own a piece of Shelter Island Heights’ history and lifestyle.
SCOTT MURPHY
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson as Scott Landis Murphy
[email protected]
Cell: (917) 440-9936
For more info, click here.
