Unique Opportunity on Shelter Island

8 & 10 Cobbetts Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Saunders Exclusive: $13,250,000
View Listing

Saunders & Associates is proud to announce a truly unique combined offering at 8 and 10 Cobbetts Lane near Dering Harbor on Shelter Island.

Two properties on the chic and sought-after Shelter Island are now available for sale as a combined listing offering the opportunity for a one-of-a-kind compound close to Dering Harbor and surrounded by hundreds of acres of forever-protected land on Shelter Island.

8 & 10 Cobbetts Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Totaling 4 acres, this special property combines an impressive newly built estate on 8 Cobbetts Lane with an additional 2 acres at 10 Cobbetts allowing the owner to create their ultimate compound with a second home or an equestrian rink.

“This property is reminiscent of large Hamptons estates of years past. Everything about it feels chic and timeless. There is nothing like this on the market anywhere out here, and the opportunity to purchase a property of this size on Shelter Island is extremely attractive” notes Jennifer Wilson of the Wilson Team.

In recent years, Shelter Island has experienced a real estate revival, with some of the Hamptons’ most elegant and refined retreats now located on the Island. Known for its relaxing pace of life and a strong sense of community, Shelter Island strikes the perfect balance between sophisticated luxury and stunning natural beauty.

This luxury estate and property are in perfect harmony with the transformation the island is currently experiencing as restorations and upgrades are underway on the many hotels and classic restaurants. Jen Wilson adds, “This property is unprecedented in the Hamptons right now and unique for the Island. The secret has gotten out and people are discovering all that is happening on Shelter Island. The sought out restaurants such as Leon & Sunset Beach are destinations that people from all over are flocking to by boat and by car. An easy trip to Sag Harbor and the North Fork makes Shelter Island even more special”.

Since its inception, Shelter Island Farm has been expertly designed to create a luxury estate that offers a premier rural lifestyle not found anywhere in the Hamptons today. Refreshing and bold with a three bay, Federal-style 6,000+/- sq. ft. main farmhouse, several hand-hewn heavy timber barns, and an elegant pool compound, all meticulously crafted for the most discerning taste. The ideal entertaining estate offers countless spaces to enjoy the unbelievable Shelter Island scenery.

“It’s exciting to imagine what you can do with 4 pristine acres on Shelter Island. Inspiration comes easy with a property this beautiful. All backing up to protected farmland, you can build another home or create an equestrian compound. Especially when you consider the already impressive property at 8 Cobbetts, the wildflower gardens, apple orchard, lavender field, and magnificent tall trees. When you add another 2 acres, there is no limit to the owners’ outdoor passions,” notes Stacey Cohen, who has represented the initial offering on 8 Cobbetts, along with the Wilson Team.

Listed Exclusively by Jennifer Wilson, Treacy Cotter and Stacey Cohen of Saunders & Associates.

Saunders & Associates, an award-winning Hamptons-based real estate firm with over $4.55 Billion sold and rented in 2021 + 2022, is the most effective and largest locally owned brokerage firm in the Hamptons, with offices in Westhampton Beach, Southampton, Bridgehampton, East Hampton and Montauk.