Everything I share here comes from my own work, my own conversations, and my own understanding of the market. These are my views, not official valuations or investment guidance in today’s market. – Sarah Minardi
Last month I shared my thoughts on Bridgehampton. Today, Montauk.
Next stop, Wainscott.
I have been studying the numbers for my own edification, and Montauk always stands apart from the rest of the South Fork. It has its own rhythm, its own personality, and its own set of buyers who come here for reasons that are not quite the same as anywhere else in the Hamptons. When I look at the past five years, I see a market that has grown steadily and confidently, shaped by people who are drawn to the edges of the island, the energy of the ocean, and the sense of freedom that Montauk gives them the moment they arrive.
Montauk has always attracted a different kind of buyer. People who want the raw coastline. People who want the surf. People who want to fish. People who want the feeling that they are slightly outside the formality of the Hamptons while still being very much part of it. Over the past five years, that audience has expanded. I have noticed more families, more long-term planners, and more buyers who want a simpler, more natural lifestyle. That shift has pushed demand across the board.
Ocean proximity drives much of the appreciation. Homes along Old Montauk Highway and the bluffs have always commanded attention, but the interest has intensified in recent years. When a renovated home with strong ocean views becomes available, the calls come quickly. Buyers know there is nothing else quite like this coastline. The dramatic landscape carries a kind of emotional weight, and that has shown up clearly in the pricing.
The Hither Hills area has also become a strong driver of appreciation. The private beach access, the family-friendly feel, and the classic Montauk aesthetic make it one of the most consistently sought-after pockets. Over the past five years, renovated homes here have jumped in value as more buyers realize how special that combination is. Even smaller cottages in Hither Hills have seen meaningful appreciation when they are well maintained or thoughtfully updated.
Ditch Plains tells its own story. Surfers have always known what makes this spot unique, but families and second-home buyers have followed. Homes near the beach path, even modest ones, rarely stay on the market for long. The energy around Ditch Plains is unlike any other part of the Hamptons. It feels laid back, authentic, and alive. That feeling has translated directly into demand, and the appreciation reflects it.
Montauk also benefits from something intangible. A sense of escape that has grown even stronger over the past five years. No matter where you are in Montauk, the water is somewhere in sight. When I talk to buyers, they often say that Montauk helps them slow down in a way that other towns do not. That experience has value, and the market shows it. The restaurants stay busy. The hotels have reinvented themselves. While Montauk has always been about vacation, the community has remained steady. All of these pieces have helped shape a market that continues to rise.
What buyers are paying now…
Homes in Hither Hills often range from 1.8 to 5 million, depending on renovation level and proximity to the private beach paths. Ocean-view homes along Old Montauk Highway can range from 4 to 10 million, with prime bluff locations pushing much higher. Ditch Plains cottages and beach houses typically fall between 2 and 3 million, with oceanfront estates on DeForest trading above 15 million. Properties surrounding Lake Montauk, off West Lake or East Lake Drive, have traded from the upper 3s to the low 7 million range. Inland Montauk homes often sell between 1.6 and 3 million, depending on size and condition.
When I look at Montauk’s five-year story, I see a market powered by clarity. People know exactly why they come here. They come for the ocean, the quiet, the simplicity, and the feeling of being just far enough away. Appreciation in Montauk does not come from trends. It comes from identity. It comes from a lifestyle that has only grown stronger as more buyers look for meaning in the places where they spend their time.
Montauk’s rise does not surprise me. It feels inevitable. It is one of the most distinct and emotionally resonant real estate stories on the South Fork, and I expect it to stay that way for years to come. – Sarah Minardi
Examples of Montauk Homes Sold Since 2025
HITHER HILLS
- 10 Jefferson Road
Sold in June 2025 for $2,150,000
A well-maintained Hither Hills home offering approximately 2,500 square feet across three levels, with private beach association access and room for a pool. Sales like this highlight the continued demand for properties that combine livability, flexibility, and proximity to the ocean within one of Montauk’s most established coastal communities.
- 33 Taft Drive
Sold in April 2025 for $5,000,000
A 2019-built Hither Hills home combining modern design, ocean proximity, and a fully turnkey layout across multiple levels. Sales like this highlight the growing demand for newer construction in Montauk, where buyers are prioritizing clean finishes, functional layouts, and immediate access to the lifestyle without the need for renovation.
OCEANVIEW
- 57 Seaview Avenue
Sold in June 2025 for $4,775,000
A newly completed Montauk home designed by Robert McKinley, known for projects like Surf Lodge, Ruschmeyer’s, and Sant Ambroeus, blending a reimagined bungalow style with modern coastal living. Properties like this draw attention for their design pedigree and distinct point of view, where architecture and interiors are as much a part of the appeal as location.
- 225 Old Montauk Highway
Sold in December 2025 for $10,500,000
A West Chin-designed estate set at one of Montauk’s highest vantage points, combining modern architecture, expansive square footage, and uninterrupted ocean views. Homes at this level of scale and elevation remain limited, with design, privacy, and outlook shaping how they are received in the market.
DITCH PLAINS
- 21 Flagg Avenue
Sold in November 2025 for $2,520,000
A Ditch Plains beach cottage just steps from the ocean, offering a simple, updated layout and direct access to one of Montauk’s most active surf areas. Homes at this scale continue to draw interest for their immediacy and location, where proximity to the beach often carries more weight than size.
- 42 DeForest Road
Sold in September 2025 for $17,000,000
A newly completed oceanfront home in Ditch Plains within the On The Break enclave, combining direct frontage, modern construction, and significant scale. In this part of Montauk, the relationship to the water and the surf culture of the area plays a central role, with location carrying a distinct weight alongside the home itself.
ON LAKE MONTAUK (WEST SIDE)
- 24 Lakeside Court
Sold in November 2025 for $5,470,000
A contemporary lakefront home with approximately 3,500 square feet of living space,
156 feet of frontage, and expansive views across Lake Montauk. Homes in these settings tend to be defined by light, openness, and a quieter relationship to the water, where privacy and outlook shape the overall experience.
- 335 East Lake Drive
Sold in February 2025 for $7,300,000
A waterfront home on Lake Montauk offering approximately 5,700 square feet of living space, direct frontage, and expansive views across nearly an acre of land. Properties along the lake tend to appeal for their calmer setting and open water exposure, offering a different experience from the oceanfront while still maintaining a strong connection to the water.
ON THE BLUFFS
- 408 Old Montauk Highway
Sold in December 2025 for $12,500,000
A historic oceanfront estate known as The Stone House, set on over three acres along Old Montauk Highway with expansive frontage, elevated bluff positioning, and views toward the lighthouse and Block Island. Properties like this are defined by a combination of scale, history, and setting, where architectural character and long-held provenance shape their place in the Montauk landscape.
- 644 Old Montauk Highway
Sold in June 2025 for $14,375,000
A three-bedroom oceanfront home with direct frontage, expansive views, and additional guest space above a detached garage. In Montauk, properties of this scale often appeal for their straightforward approach to ocean living, where proximity and ease shape the experience more than size.
INLAND
- 157 Greenwich Street
Sold in June 2025 for $1,450,000
A four-bedroom home with a split-level layout, offering solid structure and room for expansion, including a flagged area for a pool. Homes like this tend to appeal for their flexibility, where location and underlying structure create an opportunity for renovation or long-term customization.
- 48 Mulford Avenue
Sold in May 2025 for $1,750,000
A renovated single-level home in Montauk’s Soundview Association, located just off the bay with a separate guest suite and flexible layout. Properties in this area are often shaped by their proximity to the marina and bay beaches, where ease of use and access to local activity play a central role.
Homes on the Market in Montauk
On the market for $1,675,000
A four-bedroom home on Fairview Avenue with a finished lower level and the kind of proportions that allow for change. The location does much of the work here, close to town, beaches, and Montauk Downs, where access and everyday usability become part of the appeal.
- 33 Agnew Avenue
On the market for $2,600,000
A three-bedroom plus loft beach house in Ditch Plains with an open layout and easy flow to multiple outdoor spaces. The appeal here is in how simply the house connects to the beach, where the rhythm of indoor-outdoor living becomes part of everyday use rather than something added on.
- 15 Edgemere Street
On the market for $4,699,000
A well-maintained three-bedroom home set on an elevated acre with open views over the Long Island Sound. The property combines a quiet, private setting with close proximity to town, the harbor, and ocean beaches, offering a layout that supports both everyday living and easy entertaining.
- 29 Monroe Drive
On the market for $5,995,000
A newly built six-bedroom home on Monroe Drive with ocean views, a full lower level, and a layout centered on open living and outdoor connection. What stands out is how complete the environment feels, where scale, finish, and functionality are aligned from the start.
- 113 S. Edgemere Street
On the market for $6,295,000
A newly constructed waterfront home overlooking Fort Pond, offering over 7,000 square feet of living space across three levels, with a layout oriented toward the water. The experience here is shaped by how consistently the house returns to that view, from the main living spaces to the upper level and out to the pool and terraces.
- 16 & 18 Wills Point Road
On the market for $9,495,000
A two-lot offering on Wills Point Road in Culloden Point, combining over 6,000 square feet of living space with bay views, strong sunset exposure, and a private cul-de-sac setting. The opportunity here sits in the control it offers, where scale, positioning, and the additional parcel allow for a more deliberate long-term buildout.
Wrapping Up
When I look across Montauk, what stands out is not just the level of pricing, but how clearly demand has centered around experience and location. Over the past five years, the strongest appreciation has followed ocean proximity, view corridors, and access to the coastline rather than interior convenience. Whether it is the bluffs along Old Montauk Highway, the private beach paths in Hither Hills, or the energy of Ditch Plains, buyers have consistently prioritized connection to the water and the lifestyle that comes with it. These areas each offer something different, but they share a common thread: a sense of freedom that feels increasingly rare. As the market continues to evolve, the parts of Montauk that deliver that direct connection to the ocean and a more grounded way of living are the ones where value continues to build.
