The Hamptons’ 12 Best Wood-Burning Fireplaces for Santa Visits

In honor of the 12 Days of Christmas, we’re highlighting the Hamptons’ 12 best wood-burning fireplaces for visits from Santa this holiday season. You know the Hamptons is beautiful in the Summer, but these 12 homes are just as wonderful in the winter.

Some criteria: we are only including wood-burning fireplaces for this list. Call us traditional. No lumps to gas and electric fireplaces, but we have it on good authority that Santa prefers a wood-burning fireplace.

All these properties are currently for sale – ranging from under $2M to over $20M and spanning traditional to modern architectural styles. Reach out to the agent today to explore your future holiday escape in the Hamptons!

335 Town Lane, Amagansett | $21M | Represented by Scott Bradley

Santa will have his choice of 3 beautiful fireplaces when he visits this Amagansett Estate.

118 Georgica Close Road, East Hampton | $7.5M | Represented by the Jennifer Wilson Team

Everyone knows that Santa is a fan of mid-century modern design (who isn’t?), so this gorgeous modern home in Georgica isn’t getting any coal this season!

29 Quantuck Bay Lane, Quiogue | $4.599M | Represented by Aimee Martin

Like anyone else who visits this waterfront home, expect Santa to stick around and marvel at the waterviews.

54 Cobb Isle Road, Water Mill | $13.495M | Represented by The Vince Horcasitas Team

These are the fireplaces that got Santa in the gift-giving game to begin with. Also, this mantle is made for some warm cookies!

45 Whippoorwill Lane, East Quogue | $1.975M | Represented by Rod Cummings

This fireplace is the heart of the home with a magnificent masonry chimney and hearth – beware if you challenge Santa to a quick game of tennis, he has a nasty backhand.

98 Bay Street, Sag Harbor Village | $6.95M | Represented by Ed Gaetjens & The Wines Team

Did you know that Santa Claus summers in Sag Harbor Village?

8 Cove Way, Shelter Island | $4.25M | Represented by Stacey Cohen

Shelter Island is one of Santa’s favorite places in the Hamptons – and it goes without saying he appreciates a well-sized fireplace and hearth.

73 Jericho Road, East Hampton | $13.5M | Represented by Vince Horcasitas

This brand-new construction awaits its first holiday celebrations and visit from the North Pole!

121 Elm Street, Southampton Village | $9.295M | Represented by The Oakley-Leicht Team

Santa remembers this fireplace from his visits to the former mayor of Southampton all the way back in the 1800s. We know he will appreciate this historic renovation’s return to form.

473 North Sea Mecox Bay Road, Southampton | $11.995M | Represented by Laura White

On 2.3 acres in the heart of Hamptons’ horse country, don’t be surprised to see Santa’s reindeer working on their equestrian flatwork and jumping form.

24 On The Bluff, Sag Harbor | $16.5M | Represented by Laura White

Walls as sculpture with a striking and integrated built-in fireplace? Don’t be surprised if Santa puts in an offer to move from the North Pole to North Haven to this stunning modern on the bluffs.