Love is in the air, and the day of roses, stuffed teddy bears, and couples fighting over dinner reservations is approaching! Hamptons.com has your back, and we’ve curated a special Valentine’s Day Dinner guide to help you make the perfect reservation.
Nick & Toni’s
Located at 136 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937
Known for its seasonally inspired meals and extensive drinks program, lovebirds will enjoy a special Valentine’s Day Dinner featuring a diverse four-course meal. There are options for each course, but we recommend the roasted beet salad, wood-roasted local oysters, grilled lamb rack, and a Tartufo to share with your loved one.
1770 House Restaurant & Inn
Located at 143 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937
Executive Chef Michael Rozzi presents a sophisticated fine dining menu of New American cuisine in the candlelit dining room and on the starlit garden patio. Additionally, there is pub-style fare available in the inn’s casual downstairs Tavern. Celebration dishes for Valentine’s Day include appetizers such as 1770 House Ora King salmon gravlax with baby beets, caraway crema, quail egg, and everything bagel crumble; 24-month prosciutto di Parma with whipped ricotta, hen-of-the-woods mushrooms, Madeira syrup, walnut oil, and focaccia; lobster and avocado salad with frisée, smoked trout caviar, and tarragon; and artisan rigatoni alla buttera with house porcelet sausage, olive oil-cured tomatoes, peas, and Calabrian chiles.
The American Hotel
Located at 45 Main St #3012, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Fresh local foods, great seafood, exquisite shellfish, peerless meats, and fowl are prepared in classically grounded, time-tested preparations by a veteran staff. The restaurant is elegantly decorated with low lighting, setting the perfect mood for a Valentine’s Day dinner. Diners will enjoy a three-course dinner with various options.
31 W. Water Street Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Treat your sweetheart to a candlelit dinner at Baron’s Cove. The chef’s special Valentine’s Day menu features locally sourced ingredients. Enjoy a three-course dinner with a variety of options to choose from. Our ideal dinner would include their seared foie gras, peppercorn-crusted 10 oz. NY strip steak, and a petite red velvet cake.
One Ocean Road, Bridgehampton, NY
If your sweetheart prefers a unique menu, then Almond is the perfect restaurant. Enjoy a four-course meal that will have you trying something new and delicious. They have many options, but we have our eyes on the oysters, Crescent Farm Duck Breast, Happy Valley Beef Bresaola, and blood orange and chocolate dessert.
30 Main St, Southampton, NY 11968
Sant Ambroeus is known for its culinary expertise, making it the perfect place to celebrate Valentine’s Day with your loved one. You can choose from their special Valentine’s Day menus or their traditional menu. Their Valentine’s Day menu features Ricotta and Beet Ravioli and a White Chocolate Strawberry Dome.
Good Ground Tavern at The Canoe Place
239 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
Award-winning Executive Chef Ülfet Ralph focuses on locally sourced ingredients and prepares them beautifully. Her carefully crafted Valentine’s Day menu features Oysters on the half shell, hand-cut fusilli, pan-roasted scallops, cherrywood-grilled American Wagyu sirloin, strawberry shortcake, and a dark chocolate mousse.
149 Main St, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
A restaurant known for its exquisite entrées and hand-crafted cocktails. Your loved one will fall in love with their perfectly balanced “Berry in Love” cocktail. We recommend their Lobster Ravioli and New Zealand Lamb Rack. Share their flourless chocolate cake and fresh berry bruschetta.