A Slice of Paradise: Pizza in the Hamptons

Everybody loves pizza. Even when you’re in the Hamptons, you’re gonna want to get Pizza. It’s easy, fast, and nobody complains (unless you only get ‘Hawai’ian’). There are plenty of places for dates and elevated fine dining in the Hamptons, but when you’ve got hungry mouths to feed (yours included), sometimes you don’t need to overthink it – order a pizza and enjoy your night!

Hamptons.com has conducted an exhaustive guide to the Hamptons’ many pizza parlors, some subjective suggestions from our editorial team, local pizza lovers, and even our resident food-lover (not really a critic because he loves food so much), Dave Rattiner.

Crazy Pizza (East Hampton Village) – New 

Crazy Pizza brings unapologetically good pizza to the heart of East Hampton Village. The vibe is playful but the food is serious—crispy crust, quality toppings, and a sauce that hits just right. It’s the kind of place where one slice turns into three before you even sit down. Bonus points for their cheeky branding and late-night appeal.

Fini Pizza (Amagansett)  – Author’s Favorite

Opened in Summer 2023, Fini Pizza has made an instant impact. People love this pizza. I’ve driven from Bridgehampton to Amagansett on my lunch break for a slice of the lemon pie. A little bit fancier than most pizza, but its certainly not overly complicated or a “deconstruction,” this is just fantastic pizza.

Springs Pizza (Springs) – HIDDEN GEM

Local favorite, its always buzzing inside. Owned and operated by an East Hampton local, John knows what the Hamptons community needs. Springs Pizza gets an immediate boost because they are open year-round. They’ve got great salads and wings, so don’t sleep on the rest of the menu – plus, pick up a 4-pack of Lazy Lightning IPA by Springs Brewery – the perfect pair.

Fierro’s Pizza (East Hampton Village)

Fierro’s is pizza, the East Hampton Way, and now the Montauk Way since last summer. More than a pizzeria with healthy options and dietary restriction accommodations. A classic Italian restaurant with counter-service, it offers round and square pizzas, chicken wings, and hot subs. 

Sag Pizza (Sag Harbor Village)

People love their sauce and the atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between upscale and casual. Sag Pizza has a great wine selection and the outdoor seating let you enjoy the sights of Sag Harbor Village while you dine. Dinner specials are broad and are an excellent way to give everybody in your party what they’re craving. 

American Pie Pizzeria (Bridgehampton)

“Be Warm, Be Welcome, Be at Home.” American Pie PIzzaria’s headline says it all. Casual and comfortable, this is the best place to grab a slice during lunch. Affordable and convenient and the “Senor Blanco” is my favorite white slice in the Hamptons.

La Capanina (Wainscott)

Do you have the number memorized? La Capanina is the Hamptons’ most iconic pizza place in the Hamptons. You can’t miss it when you’re driving down Montauk Highway. Inside, the sounds and smells will make you think you’re in the City, but the pizza is classic with amazing crust (nobody gives these pizza bones to the dogs). Order ahead and pick up when you’re coming into East Hampton from the city.

Pellegrino’s Pizza Bar & Restaurant (North Sea / Southampton Town)

Settle the argument over which is better: NY-style or Italian Pizza. Pellegrino’s Pizza Bar and Restaurant has both and you can be the decider. Their ovens are super duper hot and they only use the best ingredients. ALSO, you should absolutely get one of their cocktails delivered if you’re not eating in.

La Parmigiana (Southampton Village)

Qualita Superiore. La Parmigiana has been here forever for a reason. Casual Italian classics and comfort food served in family-style portions. Seriously, if you’re hungry in Southampton, La Parm will fix you right up.

Tonino’s Pizza (Westhampton Beach)

Open since 1992, Tonino’s is a Westhampton Beach institution. If you are needing an event or private party catered, Tonino’s has you covered. It offers inventive pies, gourmet slices, and classic Italian dishes in an airy cafe with a patio.

The Pizza Place (Hampton Bays)

“United By Pizza.” I agree, what a great sentiment! Family-focused restaurant specializing in fresh, homemade Italian and Latin cuisine. Beyond their great pizza, check out The Pizza Place’s Latin menu for expanded offerings, including ceviche and arroz con mariscos.