Exploring Hampton Bays with Vincent Pescatore

If you haven’t been to Hampton Bays this Summer, you’re missing out. The Hamlet is not “up-and-coming,” it’s already there – fantastic restaurants, culture, nightlife, and of course, blissful beaches. But – don’t take the word of some guy who lives in Springs, let’s explore with someone who knows Hampton Bays like it’s his job. Actually, as a real estate agent, understanding what makes life in Hampton Bays special is Vince Pescatore’s job.

What’s life like in Hampton Bays? The elevator pitch.

It’s beautiful—no surprise there. I live just a stone’s throw from the ocean. Hampton Bays still feels more approachable than the rest of the Hamptons. You’ve got quick access to amazing beaches, plus you’re close to Southampton, Westhampton, and even Riverhead. The train to the city makes it easy to pop in and out. It’s a true year-round community, and honestly? It’s one of the most underrated places out here—but probably not for long.

What’s most underrated about Hampton Bays?

The waterfront—we’re surrounded by it. It’s in the name! There are probably ten spots you can boat right up to for a meal. Ponquogue Beach is a local favorite and really well-maintained with food and facilities. And the amount of protected land around here. Gorgeous trails, scenic walks, preserved waterfronts—it’s all part of the daily backdrop. And then you’ve got places like Good Ground Park in the village and Red Creek Park with pickleball, baseball—it’s all got a genuine community vibe. There’s always something going on.

Best beach for an afternoon with family?

Meschutt Beach is perfect if you’ve got younger kids—it’s a bay beach, mellow waves, food, drinks, sometimes even live music. East and West Landing are low-key gems, too. Great for sunsets and bonfires. And of course, Ponquogue is the crown jewel—just an incredible beach.

What’s your favorite area in Hampton Bays?

I’ve got to highlight the South Side—that’s where I live. You’ve got that stretch along Shinnecock Road with some great restaurants, Hampton Coffee, and then right across to Foster Avenue with even more dining spots and the fish market. It’s got that real summer energy. Crossing the Ponquogue Bridge is a moment every time—the views from the top are wild. You can see both the bay and the ocean. The whole area’s buzzing—people out biking, running, heading to the beach or grabbing a bite. I’ve actually got some off-market properties coming soon in this part of town—feel free to reach out if you’re curious.

Favorite new restaurant for 2025?

Amalfi is really making a name for itself. It might not feel exactly like the old Hampton Bays scene—it’s a bit glossier—but it’s right on the water, live music every Saturday, and the branzino is my go-to. Don’t sleep on that place.

Favorite Hampton Bays classic restaurant?

Cowfish may not be ancient, but it’s become a staple. Total Hampton Bays vibe. Everyone knows it and it never disappoints. And if you want super casual, Francesca’s is great—simple, no fuss, just good food.

What about Latin food?

Guava is the spot if you’re craving really good Spanish food. And for tacos? Hands down, Mi Pueblito. Order them to-go—they’re ridiculously good.

What’s up at Canoe Place?

Canoe Place is in its third season now, and it’s really something special. People forget it’s even in Hampton Bays! There’s always something going on—live music, comedy nights, car shows. It’s got that elevated feel, but it’s still laid back. I love grabbing a coffee there and getting some work done. Even in winter, they build bonfires—such a great off-season hang.

Favorite bar?

For a casual drink, Rumba is tough to beat. Oakland’s is another great one, especially on the weekends—awesome outdoor bar with views of the boats. Dockers is technically Quogue, but it’s right there and the Sunday scene is great for families—live music, an outdoor food stand, plus the full sit-down restaurant if you want to step it up.